TKay @TKay - 7mo
NIPs acceptance don’t adhere to any formal process at this point...Or at least thats how I feel about it. We are using NIPs as the birth place of nostr…. they really shouldn’t be. Once something is completely implemented, tested, and agreed upon on a large scale. Then it should become official. We need a NIPs purge.
Cameri @Cameri - 7mo
One issue I see is that NIPs don’t go through stages like TC39 proposals do. NIPs require at least one working implementation, not that most major clients implement it. It would be counterproductive to require major client or relay to support every single NIP before it becomes official.
One implementation is not enough. It needs at least 5 recognizable implementations with all 5 clients commenting on the GitHub NIP signaling full implementation. 1-3 clients is not enough. No merge process is too loose.
